
"I Should": The Trap of 'Should' in Life, Career and Leadership
Unseen but powerful, hundreds of “shoulds” shape your choices, without you knowing and years before you perhaps realise they exist. Like an invisible prison, they limit your freedom, direction, and potential. Your language and inner dialogue are littered with ‘shoulds’.
In conversations you say “I should be kinder”, “I should be further in my career by now” and “I should be more decisive as a leader.”. Your listener nods, maybe offers a well-meaning “You’re doing fine.” But nothing shifts. Your words are not surface-level, this is not semantics, your words directly reflect deeper beliefs running inside you.
Internally, the voice is sharper than what you allow to pass your lips, “I should be a better person”, “I should have it all figured out by now” or “I should have everything under control.”
Your words are symptoms. They reflect your inner landscape. Your inner landscape is not set in stone, it’s highly malleable when you approach it with the right tools. This landscape was shaped from your family, culture, and childhood, and created an invisible framework you mistake for truth.
🎯 Takeaway: Your life decisions are shaped by beliefs you never consciously choose, and you remain bound to until they are surfaced and questioned.
Living Inside the Box
Your rules feel like reality. Walking around with beliefs like “I should have everything under control” quietly narrows your options, blocks authentic desire, and restricts your potential. The discomfort or stuckness you feel in certain areas of life is not a flaw. It’s not that something is wrong with you. It’s a signal. A pressure point inviting you to look more closely. Dig here it says.
Your beliefs are a box. The pressure you feel is a doorway. The obstacle is always the way. You mistake internal pressure as a reason to try harder or to fix yourself, or hide your flaws. Yet the truth is the pressure is a door is ready to open.
These beliefs served you once, at some point they were needed in that moment, but now they are outdated. Congratulations on your growth.
🎯 Takeaway: “Shoulds” limit what you do and distort what you think is possible. They are costing you happiness, ease and greater success.
Who Said That?
The turning point begins when you pause and ask: Where did this belief come from? Is it mine? Does it serve me now? Is it true? Questioning and awareness break the trance and brings you back to agency.
In a session this weekend, a client was carrying a dense network of inherited beliefs. As we caught them in real time, named them, and questioned them, it was like switching on a torch in a dark room. A web of invisible rules and messages came into view, with tripwires stretched across every area of his life. No wonder he felt stuck. These rules weren’t designed to trap him—they were built to keep him safe. But now, decades later, they were doing the opposite. What once protected him was now keeping him small. The ‘problem’ wasn’t a problem, the ‘problem’ and suffering are signals that he was bumping up against beliefs that were no longer needed. Growth was underway and literally showing him the path to freedom. He just needs to understand how.
The goal wasn’t to dismantle the entire web at once. It was to help him see it first. And in seeing it, begin to reclaim his power. The work becomes learning to notice them in real time, questioning them in real time, and slowly unravelling what no longer serves. You could call this a practise, I like to call it a skill. One we were never taught by our family, school or workplaces.
Many of these beliefs are old. Formed in thousands of forgotten childhood moments. A glance from a parent. A harsh word from a teacher. A rule absorbed in the schoolyard. Ask me 10 years ago about this and I would have laughed, ask me today and I say that these rules are the single biggest opportunity in our lives for freedom, and infinite potential.
🎯 Takeaway: Consciously questioning the origin of your beliefs is the first step toward reclaiming your freedom.
Stepping Beyond the Known Path
Letting go of “should” means clarity. But first you need to step beyond the known, this is uncomfortable and unclear. Unclarity allows clarity.
‘Shoulds’ you can’t see block access to the ‘shoulds’ you can see, stacked up like a Jenga tower, making it frustrating and confusing. You might resist a healing path because you shouldn’t need anybody else, you should be able to do it yourself, you should work harder which means that your quiet suffering is ‘normal’. The path ahead will not be what you planned, or what others expect. But it’s more alive, more expansive, and more true to you. Who are you here to be, if not you?
Your rules can be hard to see from the inside. As you read these words you will know through flickers of clarity whether this is helpful for you. In the second moment however, don’t let this clarity close by worrying about how, or why you can’t consciously see your beliefs yet. They’re baked into your internal world, blended over decades so much that a lot of it feels like you, yet it isn’t.
If you’ve always been praised for being strong, it’s hard to spot the belief “I should never show weakness.” because you believe it so deeply. If your whole career has been built on productivity, it’s hard to question “I should always be doing something.” These patterns feel like personality. They feel like truth. Which is why they’re so hard to catch alone.
You need space. A place to speak freely. A container where language becomes a mirror. Where someone can hear what you’re saying and reflect it back to you with fresh eyes. Once the belief is spoken aloud, you can go inward and meet it. Explore what part of you still holds it.
When you do, something begins to open. A new option appears. A new possibility. That’s how change really begins.
🎯 Takeaway: The beliefs that limit you often feel like your personality, like you. They sound like truth. This is why they’re so hard to see alone.
Freedom
When ‘shoulds’ begin to clear, something subtle but profound happens. The weight lifts. The internal tripwires and cobwebs no longer hold you in place.
You feel movement again. Lightness. Space. You forgot yourself. Yet you were always there, worried and suffering that something was wrong, but it wasn’t. Everything was right, you were growing, sensing, just lacking the tools.
Without the invisible rules dictating who you should be, you’re free to discover who you actually are. Free to make decisions without pressure. Free to follow what feels right, even if it makes no sense to anyone else. Free to be at ease amidst a high-performance environment, free to take your authentic leadership to new levels, free to lay in bed peaceful and whole.
No holiday, prestige vehicle, or position title can give you this kind of peace. This is inner space reclaimed. This is cleaning your house—the one you live inside every day. This is the shift from living as a victim of your programming to choosing how you meet life.
A life no longer bound by “should” and instead by “I choose”.
🎯 Takeaway: Real freedom is not external. It’s the ability to move, choose, and lead from your truth unburdened by the beliefs that once kept you safe, but now keep you small.
💡 Mike McGregor | Transformational Coach: Evidence-based coaching solutions for professionals and leaders committed to unlocking their full potential.
Who I work with:
-
Professionals navigating life transitions such; career, identity, purpose.
-
Leaders building capability, authenticity and presence.
If you want to know what’s driving your own patterns, that’s why I built Momentum. See Momentum.

Keep Reading
Nothing Changes if Nothing Changes.
What are you consciously changing in your life right now? Answer this.

Wilful Blindness
‘Wilful Blindness’ occurs when we deny a reality or truth in order to remain ‘feeling’ safe.

The Everyday Unconscious: Real Moments From This Week
Transformation attempts are like seeds in the soil. Most never take root.


